ERISA-In Response To Fifth Circuit’s Vacating The New Fiduciary Rule And Related Exemptive Relief, DOL Announces Temporary Enforcement Policy On Prohibited Transactions Rules Applicable To Investment Advice Fiduciaries

In Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2018-02 (the “FAB”), the U.S. Department of Labor (the “DOL”) announces a temporary enforcement policy on prohibited transaction rules that apply to investment advice fiduciaries, to help them handle the recent decision from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals vacating the DOL’s New Fiduciary Rule and related exemptive relief.  Here is what the FAB says:


This document announces a temporary enforcement policy related to the DOL’s rule defining who is a “fiduciary” under ERISA and the Internal Revenue Code (the “Code”), and the associated prohibited transaction exemptions, including the Best Interest Contract Exemption (the “BIC Exemption”), the Class Exemption for Principal Transactions In Certain Assets Between Investment Advice Fiduciaries and Employee Benefit Plans and IRAs (the “Principal Transactions Exemption”), and certain amended prohibited transaction exemptions (collectively, the “PTEs”).

The DOL’s rule, entitled “Definition of the Term ‘Fiduciary’; Conflict of Interest Rule — Retirement Investment Advice,” (for convenience, the “New Fiduciary Rule”) the BIC and Principal Transactions Exemptions, and the amendments to existing PTEs became applicable on June 9, 2017.  The DOL delayed the applicability date of certain provisions in the PTEs to provide an extended transition period through July 1, 2019, to consider possible changes or modifications to the New Fiduciary Rule and PTEs.  During the extended transition period, the BIC Exemption and Principal Transactions Exemption provided broad relief from certain prohibited transactions provisions of ERISA and the Code for investment advice fiduciaries that satisfied the “impartial conduct standards” set out in those exemptions. Further, the DOL adopted a temporary enforcement policy stating that it would not pursue claims against fiduciaries who were working in good faith to comply with the New Fiduciary Rule and applicable provisions of the PTEs, or treat those fiduciaries as being in violation of the New Fiduciary Rule and PTEs.  In response to these developments, many financial institutions created and implemented compliance structures designed to ensure satisfaction of the impartial conduct standards.

On or about May 7, 2018, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit is expected to issue a mandate effectuating its opinion vacating the entire New Fiduciary Rule, the BIC Exemption, the Principal Transactions Exemption, and related amendments to existing PTEs.  The DOL understands that financial institutions, advisers, and retirement investors may have questions regarding the investment advice fiduciary definition and related exemptive relief following the court’s order.  The DOL intends to provide appropriate guidance in the future.  At this point, however, the DOL is aware that some financial institutions may be uncertain as to the breadth of the prohibited transaction exemptions that remain available for investment advice fiduciaries following the court’s order.  The uncertainty about fiduciary obligations and the scope of exemptive relief could disrupt existing investment advice arrangements to the detriment of retirement plans, retirement investors, and financial institutions.  Further, some financial institutions have devoted significant resources to comply with the BIC Exemption and the Principal Transactions Exemption and may prefer to continue to rely upon the new compliance structures.

Based upon these concerns, the DOL has concluded that financial institutions should be permitted to continue to rely upon the temporary enforcement policy, pending the DOL’s issuance of additional guidance.  The DOL is convinced that this temporary enforcement relief is appropriate and in the interest of plans, plan fiduciaries, plan participants and beneficiaries, IRAs, and IRA owners.

Temporary Enforcement Policy

Accordingly, for the period from June 9, 2017, until after regulations or exemptions or other administrative guidance has been issued, the DOLwill not pursue prohibited transactions claims against investment advice fiduciaries who are working diligently and in good faith to comply with the impartial conduct standards for transactions that would have been exempted in the BIC Exemption and Principal Transactions Exemption, or treat such fiduciaries as violating the applicable prohibited transaction rules.  Of course, investment advice fiduciaries may also choose to rely upon other available exemptions to the extent applicable after the Fifth Circuit’s decision, but the Department will not treat an adviser’s failure to rely upon such other exemptions as resulting in a violation of the prohibited transaction rules if the adviser meets the terms of this enforcement policy.

The Department is evaluating the need for other temporary or permanent prohibited transaction relief for investment advice fiduciaries, including possible prospective and retroactive prohibited transaction relief.  The Department will, of course, consider any applications for additional relief.