In Springer v. Cleveland Clinic Emple. Health Plan Total Care, No. 17-4181 (6th Cir. 2018), Jason Springer arranged air ambulance transportation for his son before his employee benefit plan (the “Plan”) could verify his membership and authorize the service. Subsequently, the plan administrator denied Springer’s claim for coverage because he did not obtain the precertification required for nonemergency transportation. The district court affirmed the denial and alternatively found that Springer did not suffer an injury to have Article III standing.
Upon reviewing the case, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals (the “Court”) said that Springer has standing to bring his claim. The denial of plan benefits is a concrete injury for Article III standing. However, the Court also said that it agrees with the district court that the plain language of the Plan required precertification. Springer’s son’s transportation was not an emergency which could be used to sidestep the precertification process. Accordingly, the Court affirmed the district courts’ decision.